Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brenden O'Donnell's avatar

So good. The specificity of these details somehow makes your story even more relatable 💜

Expand full comment
Kris Winters's avatar

Thank you for sharing this. I was afab but knew from a very early age, before pre-school, that I was a boy. I didn't know anyone thought this was a bad thing until my father exposed his transphobia in my early tweens. He is Hispanic, was a coach for many years, and maybe because of both those things and because he regretted having just me and my 2 sisters but no amab children he demanded that we both fear and appease him at all costs while also never act "like sissies." I was always more upset than my sisters when he would call us that for crying or for failing at something. I didn't understand (prior to exposure to his hatred of trans people) why he would call me, his only son, a sissy just for feeling. I didn't have the specific experience you so eloquently described here, but through the amalgamation of my father's constant rejections of everything that made me my own human instead of his property I think I came out (pun not intended in this instance) understanding that even though I grew up a boy I never wanted to become his version of A Man. By the time I moved out of his house, that was as clear to me as my always-held knowledge that I was never going to be, or identify as, a girl either. I was comfortable by then with my unspoken understanding that although I never chose being afab or being a boy inside I did not belong neatly in either gender altbough I had found by then, in my own ways and spaces, what I did admire about kind men and brave women. If I had the language then, I would have written about the struggle of knowing I was and had always been Non-Binary, but I didn't. No person had ever taken the time to explain to me yet that our ancestors had actually existed under different names for millenia, but I still felt both connected to and deliberately cut off from them - without understanding why this was or who "us" really meant. Now that I do, and now that I see others sharing and writing about their experiences in growing up trans, I feel braver and less alone than I ever dreamed was possible. We aren't exactly the same, but we are not as different as we would appear at first glance either. Existing under the trans umbrella is difficult in America and in many different iteration ms of Western Civilization, but I would still rather be me than go back to pretending I am someone or something I am not.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts